 
          1437
        
        
          Technical Committee 203 /
        
        
          
            Comité technique 203
          
        
        
          Figure 4. Typical pore pressure recording a full liquefying impact. The
        
        
          inclined dotted line reflects the time of a sensor showing liquefaction;
        
        
          the black spot at the top shows the mud weight: 9.1/0.50 = 18.2 kN/m
        
        
          3
        
        
          .
        
        
          2.3
        
        
          
            3D liquefaction effect of packing and trigger
          
        
        
          2.3.1
        
        
          
            Test setup
          
        
        
          In order to understand the three dimensional extent of excess
        
        
          pore pressures induced by partial liquefaction, several 3D tests
        
        
          in a circular tub with a diameter of 58.9 cm and a height of 46.2
        
        
          cm have been performed. The tub was carefully filled with fully
        
        
          saturated dense sand (
        
        
          
            n
          
        
        
          
        
        
          0.35) and in the top centre a small
        
        
          cylinder with a diameter and height of 20 cm was specially
        
        
          prepared with fully saturated loose sand (
        
        
          
            n
          
        
        
          
        
        
          0.43), using
        
        
          special equipment and expertise, shown in Figure 5a-c. Baskarp
        
        
          sand B15 (0.34<
        
        
          
            n
          
        
        
          <0.47,
        
        
          
        
        
          
            s
          
        
        
          = 26 kN/m
        
        
          3
        
        
          ) was used.
        
        
          Figure 5a. 3D test setup; WMs are indicated with large italic numbers
        
        
          Ten micro sensors for measuring pore pressures were placed
        
        
          on a fixed frame, two of which in the centre of the loose sand
        
        
          cylinder (nr 1 and 2) and the others under and aside the loose
        
        
          sand, as shown Figure 5a. From the outside, the tube was
        
        
          subjected to a series of triggers with increasing impact. First
        
        
          five times with a bullet of 0.017 kg and thereafter nine times
        
        
          with a bullet of 0.670 kg, each rolling 100 cm over the gutter at
        
        
          a slope of 20
        
        
          o
        
        
          (Figure 5d). Next, four impacts by a swing of
        
        
          5.15 kg from a horizontal distance of 100 cm, subsequently
        
        
          three with a swing weight of 25.6 kg from a horizontal distance
        
        
          of 25, 50 and 75 cm (Figure 5e), and finally the tub was lifted
        
        
          about 10 cm and dropped suddenly, imitating a quake. Thus, in
        
        
          total 21 successive phases were executed. At each impact the
        
        
          sensors recorded the induced excess pore pressures at frequency
        
        
          rate of 200 Hz, and the settlement of the loose sand surface was
        
        
          measured after every phase.
        
        
          Figure 5b. Preparing loose sand        Figure 5c. Ready for testing.
        
        
          Figure 5d. Rolling trigger bullet system        Figure 5e. Trigger swing
        
        
          2.3.2
        
        
          
            Recorded data, excess pore pressures
          
        
        
          Much data was collected and elaborated to illustrate the
        
        
          effect of the trigger intensity and the induced excess pore
        
        
          pressures in the loose sand volume and around in the dense
        
        
          sand. Most relevant data are collected in Table 1.
        
        
          Table 1. Relevant recorded data during subsequent phases (impacts)
        
        
          Phase Trigger
        
        
          Kg, cm 
        
        
          Liquefaction
        
        
          at WM1 sec
        
        
          Sedimentation 
        
        
          period sec 
        
        
          Settlement 
        
        
          cm 
        
        
          WM2
        
        
          max
        
        
          KPa 
        
        
          
            n
          
        
        
          % 
        
        
          1
        
        
          checking sensors 
        
        
          2 0.017 100 none
        
        
          0.8 
        
        
          0.04 
        
        
          0.412 43.0
        
        
          3 0.017 100 none
        
        
          0.7 
        
        
          0.03 
        
        
          0.380 42.8
        
        
          4 0.017 100 none
        
        
          0.6 
        
        
          0.02 
        
        
          0.353 42.7
        
        
          5 0.017 100 none
        
        
          0.6 
        
        
          0.01 
        
        
          0.335 42.7
        
        
          6 0.67 100 none
        
        
          1.0 
        
        
          0.0 
        
        
          0.638 42.7
        
        
          7 0.67 100 not registered, miscommunication ITC and lab
        
        
          8 0.67 100 none
        
        
          1.0 
        
        
          0.0 
        
        
          0.600 42.7
        
        
          9 0.67 100 none
        
        
          1.0 
        
        
          0.0 
        
        
          0.552 42.7
        
        
          10 0.67 100 none
        
        
          1.0 
        
        
          0.0 
        
        
          0.539 42.7
        
        
          11 0.67 100 none
        
        
          1.0 
        
        
          0.04 
        
        
          0.542 42.6
        
        
          12 0.67 100 none
        
        
          1.0 
        
        
          0.01 
        
        
          0.535 42.6
        
        
          13 0.67 100 none
        
        
          1.0 
        
        
          0.0 
        
        
          0.517 42.6
        
        
          14 0.67 100 none
        
        
          1.0 
        
        
          0.0 
        
        
          
            0.500
          
        
        
          42.6
        
        
          15 5.14 100 not registered, miscommunication ITC and lab
        
        
          16 5.14 100 3.0
        
        
          8.0 
        
        
          0.25 
        
        
          1.43* 42.2
        
        
          17 5.14 100 2.5
        
        
          6.5 
        
        
          0.25 
        
        
          1.43* 41.9
        
        
          18 25.6 25 2.5
        
        
          6.0 
        
        
          0.20 
        
        
          1.43* 41.5
        
        
          19 25.6 50 3.3
        
        
          7.0 
        
        
          0.20 
        
        
          1.43* 41.2
        
        
          20
        
        
          #
        
        
          25.6 75 3.3
        
        
          7.0 
        
        
          0.15 
        
        
          1.43* 41.0
        
        
          21 quake 10 3.4
        
        
          7.1 
        
        
          0.15 
        
        
          1.43* 40.8 
        
        
          * at WM2 the sand was liquefied during about 1 second 
        
        
          #
        
        
           Phase 20 taken as reference for determining the porosity  
        
        
          Considering as an indication a sedimentation coefficient
        
        
          
            s
          
        
        
          
            v
          
        
        
          
        
        
          1.5 10
        
        
          -3
        
        
          m
        
        
          2
        
        
          /s similar as in Section 2.2 (same sand), one may
        
        
          conclude that during the Phase 2 with the lightest bullet the
        
        
          liquefied zone reached only the top, less than
        
        
          
            h
          
        
        
          = (
        
        
          
            s
          
        
        
          
            v
          
        
        
          
            t
          
        
        
          2
        
        
          )
        
        
          0.5
        
        
          = 3.4